She Weeps

Senator Hillary Clinton sheds real or fake tears?

In her column for The Wall Street Journal that appeared shortly after the “Hillary moment” in New Hampshire, Peggy Noonan wrote, “Exactly 100% of the people who saw it on the news and on YouTube had one reaction. It was to ask the question: Is that real or artifice? With the Clintons you always have to ask…” With Pine & Gilmore you always have to ask: Is that Real-real? Real-fake? Fake-real? Or Fake-fake?

So watch the crying scene again on YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MVlwH7-05Fk&feature=related

Then apply the Polonius Test:
1. Being true to your own self
2. Being what you say you are to others

1. True to Self
Is:
So, was Hillary’s getting choked up true to herself? Does her real-real or fake-real self really shed tears over whether her country “falls backwards”?
Not:
Or, were her tears not true to her self? Were they not true to the otherwise self-controlled personality we’ve come to know?

2. What it says it is
Is:
Were the tears what they (the tears themselves) said they were — sincere concern expressed at the end of a weary New Hampshire campaign? Alternatively, were the tears what they (again, the tears themselves) said they were — another Clintonesque contrivance to win at all costs? (You have two ways to see as “Is.”)
Not: Or, were the tears not what they said they were, not tears at all but a bad acting job? Alternatively, were the tears not what they said they were, not tears at all but a great acting job? (Here too you have two ways to see as “Not.”)

Finally, vote:
RR: Is-Is (we had to get a Clintonian “is-is” in here somewhere!)
RF: Not-Is
FR: Is-Not
FF: Not-Not

Like they say in Hillary’s hometown of Chicago: Vote early and vote often!

And if you’ve read chapter 6, you’ll know the approach the Clinton campaign takes to pursue the Democratic nomination rides on this assessment: Does she Go Faux? Create Belief? Reveal the Unreal? Or Get Real?

Comment on this story

1 Comment about She Weeps

  1. Nathan Rice says on February 1st, 2008:

    The way I see it, the tears were real tears. but I don’t believe they were true to herself. I genuinely thought she surprised herself by the sudden emotion and then made a effort to “go with the moment”. So in using the scoring from above I lean on the Real-Fake analogy.

Email this story

E-Mail Image Verification
 Loading ...

 

Vote

Is it real? Or is it fake? Or is it somewhere in between? In order to vote, you're going to need to download the latest Flash Player...it's simple and painless and you can do it by clicking the link below.

Download the Flash Player

Subscribe to Is it real? Or is it fake? via RSS